How Much Should Employers Spend on Benefits | A Quick Guide
March 21, 2023
Employers often struggle with the question of how much they should spend on employee benefits. Providing attractive benefits packages can help companies attract and retain top talent, but there is no one-size-fits-all answer to how much should be allocated towards benefits. In this article, we will explore the various factors that employers should consider when determining their benefits budget, as well as the potential benefits and drawbacks of investing more in employee benefits. By the end of the article, readers will have a better understanding of how to approach the question of benefits spending, and how to strike the right balance between attracting and retaining talent and managing costs.
Setting a budget for employee benefits can vary depending on the company and its needs. Some experts suggest you pay 1.25 to 1.4 times each employee's base salary while others follow a simple rule to add 20-50% to the worker's salary to cover benefits.
According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, employers pay an average of $7,188 for single and $20,576 for family coverage annually[source]. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that benefits cost employers $13.17 per hour on average, accounting for 31% of total costs[source]. The average cost for insurance benefits comes to $2.73 per hour or $5,698 annually per employee[source].
Importance of employee benefits in attracting and retaining talent
Employee benefits are crucial in attracting and retaining top talent in today's competitive job market. Offering a comprehensive benefits package that goes beyond what is required by law can differentiate an employer from its competitors and make it more attractive to job seekers. Benefits are also crucial to an employee's compensation package, helping employers remain competitive.
Additionally, benefits can improve employee wellness, job satisfaction, and retention rates. A robust benefits package can also enhance an employer's brand as a desirable place to work, leading to referrals from current employees. Overall, competitive employee benefits are valuable for employers to attract and retain top talent and create a satisfied and productive workforce.
Challenges of determining benefits budget faced by Employers
Determining a benefits budget is a complex task that employers face every year. Here are some of the challenges that employers may encounter when trying to determine their benefits budget:
Rising Costs: The cost of healthcare and other benefits can increase significantly yearly, making it difficult for employers to predict their budget accurately. Employers may need to make tough decisions about the benefits they can provide their employees.
Changing Regulations: Regulations around healthcare and other benefits constantly evolve, making it difficult for employers to keep up with the latest requirements and determine how they will impact their benefits budget.
Diverse Employee Needs: Employers may have a diverse workforce with varying needs and preferences for benefits. It can be a challenge to find a benefits package that meets the needs of all employees while also fitting within the budget.
Limited Resources: Employers may need more resources to devote to benefits, especially if they are a small business. They may need to balance the cost of benefits with other expenses like salaries and overhead.
Competition for Talent: Offering competitive benefits is vital for attracting and retaining top talent. Employers may need to invest more in their benefits package to stay competitive, which can be challenging if they have a limited budget.
What are the most common benefits offered by employers?
Employers commonly offer a variety of benefits to their employees. Some of the most common benefits include:
• Health insurance
• Dental and vision insurance
• Retirement accounts
• Flexible spending accounts or health savings accounts
• Life insurance
• Paid time off, such as vacation days and sick leave
• Disability insurance
• Wellness programs and gym memberships
• Tuition assistance or reimbursement
• Childcare services or subsidies
Factors to Consider
Industry benchmarks and competitive landscape
When designing an employee benefits package, employers must consider industry benchmarks and the competitive landscape to ensure their benefits package is competitive and attractive to potential employees. Here are some key factors to consider:
Industry Benchmarks: Employers should research industry benchmarks to understand what benefits are typical for their industry and region. This can help them design a benefits package that is competitive and attractive to potential employees.
Competitor Analysis: Employers should also analyze their competitors' benefits packages to understand what benefits they are offering and how their package compares. This can help them identify gaps and opportunities to differentiate their benefits package.
Talent Pool: Employers should consider the talent pool they are trying to attract and retain. For example, if they are looking to hire millennials, they may want to offer benefits such as student loan repayment programs or flexible work arrangements.
Employee Preferences: Employers should also consider the preferences and needs of their current and potential employees. This can be done through surveys or focus groups to gather feedback on what benefits are most important to them.
Company size and budget constraints
Employee benefits can vary by industry and company size. For example, service-producing industries offer more benefits than goods-producing industries.
The company's size also affects the type and amount of benefits offered. Larger companies are more likely to offer a broader range of benefits, such as health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off[source]. Smaller companies may not be able to afford to offer as many benefits but may still provide some basic ones like paid sick leave or flexible work arrangements.
Employers are also expanding the concept of benefits beyond traditional offerings.
Companies like SES-image tag have discovered differences in employee benefit preferences across various regions and offices[source]. As a result, they offer customized benefits packages that cater to their employees' specific needs and wants. These customized packages may include wellness programs, tuition reimbursement, or pet insurance.
Employee demographics and preferences
Employers may consider various employee demographics and preferences when deciding on employee benefits to offer. Here are some factors that may be considered:
Family status: Employees with families may value benefits like child care assistance or flexible work arrangements that allow them to balance work and family responsibilities.
Income level: Lower-income employees may be more concerned with basic needs like healthcare and retirement savings. In contrast, higher-income employees may be more interested in benefits like stock options or executive perks.
Industry: Different industries may have different norms and expectations regarding employee benefits. For example, tech companies may be more likely to offer perks like free meals and onsite gyms, while healthcare companies may prioritize healthcare benefits.
Geographic location: Employers may also consider the geographic location of their employees when deciding on benefits. For example, employees in urban areas may have different transportation needs than those in rural areas.
Legal requirements and compliance
Legal requirements and compliance refer to the rules, regulations, and laws that organizations must adhere to operate legally and ethically. This includes compliance with labor laws, safety regulations, data protection laws, environmental regulations, and other relevant legislation. Failure to comply with legal requirements can result in fines, legal action, and damage to an organization's reputation.
Organizations must establish policies and procedures that promote ethical behavior, train employees on relevant regulations, conduct regular audits and assessments, and maintain accurate records to ensure compliance. By prioritizing legal compliance, organizations can minimize risk, protect their employees and customers, and demonstrate their commitment to ethical business practices.
Strategies for Maximizing Benefits Value
Maximizing benefits value is essential because employee benefits play a crucial role in attracting and retaining top talent. By offering competitive and valuable benefits, organizations can differentiate themselves in the job market and demonstrate their commitment to employee well-being.
Maximizing benefits value also helps organizations to improve employee satisfaction, engagement, and productivity. Employees who feel their employer cares about their well-being are likely to be loyal, motivated, and productive.
Conduct employee surveys to determine benefit preferences and needs.
Consider various benefits, including healthcare, retirement, and work-life balance.
Negotiate with vendors to get the best rates and deals.
Offer education and resources to help employees fully understand and utilize their benefits.
Regularly review and update benefit offerings to ensure they remain relevant and competitive.
Offering a diverse range of benefits
Companies may offer unique or innovative employee benefits to attract and retain talent. Some examples of such benefits include:
• Gym membership reimbursement
• Bike-to-work reimbursement
• Free health trackers or reimbursement for them
• Autism benefits
• Unconventional perks that ease employees' financial stress
• Pawternity leave
• Paying for your next vacation
Negotiating with vendors and carriers
Negotiating with vendors and carriers can help organizations get the best rates and deals on employee benefits. Here are some tips for successful negotiations:
Research: Before entering negotiations, research the vendor or carrier and their competitors to understand market rates and industry standards.
Set goals: Determine the specific outcomes you want to achieve through negotiations, such as cost savings, improved benefit offerings, or better service.
Build relationships: Establish a rapport with the vendor or carrier and their representatives. Relationships built on mutual respect and understanding can lead to more successful negotiations.
Leverage data: Use data to support your negotiating position, such as cost projections, utilization rates, or employee satisfaction survey results.
Be flexible: Be open to compromise and creative solutions that benefit both parties.
Get everything in writing: Document any agreements reached during negotiations to avoid misunderstandings or disputes later.
Communicating the value of benefits to employees
Communicating the value of benefits to employees is essential to ensure that they understand and appreciate the benefits that they receive. Here are some tips for effective communication:
Be clear: Use simple, easy-to-understand language and avoid jargon or technical terms. Explain the benefits and how they work in a way that employees can easily understand.
Use multiple channels: Use a variety of communication channels, such as email, newsletters, social media, and in-person meetings, to reach employees.
Highlight the benefits: Emphasize the value of each benefit and how it can help employees, such as saving money on healthcare costs, providing work-life balance, or improving retirement security.
Provide examples: Use real-life examples or case studies to illustrate how the benefits have helped other employees in similar situations.
Offer education and resources: Provide educational resources, such as workshops, webinars, or online tools, to help employees fully understand and utilize their benefits.
Encourage feedback: Encourage employees to provide feedback on the benefits program and use their input to make improvements and adjustments as needed.
Leveraging technology to streamline administration
Leveraging technology like Compport can streamline employee benefits administration, making it easier for HR departments to manage benefits and for employees to access and use them. Here are some ways technology can be used:
Online enrollment: Offer online enrollment for benefits, which can be more efficient and accurate than paper-based enrollment. Employees can access benefits information and enroll from anywhere with an internet connection.
Benefits administration software: Use benefit administration software to manage benefits, track eligibility, and process claims. This can help automate many administrative tasks and reduce errors.
Mobile apps: Offer mobile apps that allow employees to access their benefits information and claims, view their benefits history, and find in-network providers.
Telehealth services: Offer telehealth services, which provide remote access to medical care, allowing employees to consult with doctors or other healthcare professionals from their homes or offices.
Self-service portals: Provide self-service portals that allow employees to access and update their benefits information, review claims, and make changes to their coverage.
What are some examples of additional compensation benefits?
Employee benefits are additional perks or rewards offered by a company in addition to their wages or salaries[source]. Some examples of employee benefits include health insurance, medical insurance, life insurance, dental insurance, vision insurance, retirement plans, bonuses, commissions, and stock options. Other employee benefits include transportation benefits such as reimbursement for commuting expenses and gym memberships.
Employee benefits are significant because they help attract and retain quality employees. A competitive benefits package can make a company more attractive to job seekers. When comparing job offers from different companies, it is essential to consider the total compensation package rather than just the salary or wages offered. The total compensation package includes all the monetary and non-monetary rewards employees receive from their employer.
In addition to the benefits mentioned above, some companies offer other attractive perks such as flexible work schedules, work-from-home options, paid time off for volunteering or community service, and tuition reimbursement programs. These additional perks can help improve employee morale and job satisfaction.
Additional compensation benefits are non-monetary rewards or perks employers may offer their employees. Some examples of additional compensation benefits include:
• Stock options
• Profit sharing
• Equity sharing
• Performance-based pay
• Sign-on bonuses
• Relocation assistance
Other examples of additional compensation benefits can include paid time off, flexible work arrangements, and career development programs.
In conclusion, determining how much employers should spend on benefits is a complex and multifaceted decision that requires careful consideration of various factors, such as the company's financial situation, industry standards, employee needs, and competitive landscape.
While there is no one-size-fits-all approach, employers can leverage data and analytics to make informed decisions, balance the cost and value of benefits, and create a comprehensive benefits package that supports their business goals and employees' well-being.
Investing in employee benefits is essential to attract and retain top talent, increase employee productivity and job satisfaction, and improve business performance and profitability. A comprehensive benefits program can increase employee retention, improve productivity, enhance recruitment, lower healthcare costs, and tax advantages. While the ROI may vary, it can significantly impact the organization's bottom line.
Organizations can retain top talent, reduce turnover costs, and attract high-quality candidates by demonstrating a commitment to employees' well-being and providing competitive benefits. Additionally, offering preventive healthcare benefits and wellness programs can reduce healthcare costs, and fringe benefits can provide tax advantages for employers and employees.
Find out how Compport can help you manage all your Pay Transparency process, book a demo today!